We loved our stay at Never Forget! The house had almost everything we wanted, including a huge pool, nice hot tub, and direct access to the beach. The owners were awesome and extremely responsive during our stay.
The only non-trivial issue was really due to our own ignorance about Salvo; the Dollar General is very convenient (a 2-minute drive), but the closest large stores are 30 minutes away. We did stop for groceries on our way to the house (we ordered online from Food Lion) but incidental needs popped up while we were there, and we had to make a couple store runs.
Overall, we were very happy with our stay!