We really liked this place! The location was great; above a supermarket and a quick .5 mile walk to Cruz Bay. *For the market shopping we do not recommend the one directly below the rental, rather we used Dolphin market which is between this listing and the ferry. The prices at Dolphin are much better and it's only a few blocks away. *We were there in off season, so most of the shops in the plaza below were closed. We knew that was likely so it didn't bother us but if you go late Aug/early Sept plan for that. *We stayed in #10 which was very clean and open, but does not have any external windows/no natural light. We read about it in a review before we got there, so we were prepared, but it is not mentioned in the listing, so take note. We only found out a couple weeks before by reading another review so we rolled with it. *Check in was super easy and I love the key system so you don't have to bring your key. It's safely in a locked box when you leave so you never have to worry about losing it.*Everything was in good supply, clean towels, clean bedding. Just a note is they only supplied 2 rolls of TP for 8 nights for 2 people, so 1 roll per person over 8 days. We bought more while we were out. A small 4 pack at Dolphin was about 4. Overall I'd stay again, the value was very good and I felt it was super clean. The area also felt safe. We had a great time!