Photo by Aaron Bronkema

New Buffalo holiday rentals

We found 1,388 holiday rentals — enter your dates for availability

Where to?

Dates

Calendar
Flexible dates

July 2025

August 2025

Find the perfect place for you stay in New Buffalo by choosing from 265 houses, 30 apartments and other holiday rentals. Whether you're travelling with your children and pets, with friends or just your children, holiday rentals have the best amenities for hanging out with the people that matter most, which might include a garden and Wi-Fi. At the end of the day, you'll be sure to find a property to rent that has what everyone needs, including a place that's non-smoking or offers accessibility.

Holiday rentals with weekly discounts - New Buffalo

Showing deals for:3 Oct - 10 Oct

Exceptional

(40 reviews)

Sweet Inn Coach House near beautiful beach on Lake Michigan in Beachwalk

Michigan City, IN

7% off

AU$378 per night

includes taxes & fees

Exceptional

(7 reviews)

Harbor Country-Rolling Prairie Retreat on 7 private wooded acres w/heated pool

Rolling Prairie, IN

14% off

AU$612 per night

includes taxes & fees

Living Room looking to kitchen and dining room

Exceptional

(73 reviews)

Spacious 6 Bedroom Lakehouse. Private heated pool. Great for families.

New Buffalo, MI

10% off

AU$3,322 per night

includes taxes & fees

Exceptional

(61 reviews)

Harbor Country Home with Guest Cottage, Private Pool, Short Walk to Beach!

Harbert, MI

17% off

AU$721 per night

includes taxes & fees

Exceptional

(26 reviews)

Beachfront, Gorgeous 5 Bedroom Home in Michigan City, IN (Sleeps 14)

Michigan City, IN

12% off

AU$2,870 per night

includes taxes & fees

Exceptional

(23 reviews)

Summer Vacation Home or Weekend Get Away - 5 minute walk to Lake Michigan

Michigan City, IN

8% off

AU$1,191 per night

includes taxes & fees

Exceptional

(69 reviews)

Red Oak-5 bedroom with in ground pool, fireplace-walk to restaurants

New Buffalo, MI

8% off

AU$1,173 per night

includes taxes & fees

Wonderful

(5 reviews)

Schoolhouse now 5K Sq ft Lux BNB: Gym, Sauna, HotTub, GameRoom, Billiards, pets

Union Pier, MI

13% off

AU$2,597 per night

includes taxes & fees

Exceptional

(8 reviews)

Lakefront home! Water view from the house. Less than 3 minutes stroll to beach!

Michigan City, IN

8% off

AU$2,109 per night

includes taxes & fees

Wonderful

(22 reviews)

Spacious 5 bedroom home with private pool, hot tub & 10 minute walk to the beach

New Buffalo, MI

8% off

AU$1,030 per night

includes taxes & fees

Find spaces that suit your style

House

Condo/Apartment

Find the best place to stay - New Buffalo

The Neighborhood Hotel - Grand Beach

Sleeps 2 · 1 bedroom

Warm late summer dates still open in Sept 2025: 1-4, 7-11, 15-19, 21-26. Enjoy!

Sleeps 12 · 6 bedrooms · 3+ bathrooms

Peace of mind
Our Book with Confidence Guarantee gives you 24/7 support
More quality time
From booking to staying, the whole process is simple and enjoyable
All the privacy of home
Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, gardens and more
More for less
More space, more privacy, more amenities — more value

The cosy area of New Buffalo awaits your stay

The beaches, lake and wildlife display a scene truly unique to New Buffalo. This city's casino gaming, bird watching and restaurants draw many visitors. Many of our holiday rentals offer full kitchens, spacious living quarters and sometimes even a hot tub—perfect for a relaxing getaway.

Sightseeing in and around New Buffalo

Do you want to find top things to see and do during your stay? Venture out of your cosy holiday rental and experience everything that makes New Buffalo a fun place to get away to. These are some of the most popular attractions to put on your list, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city centre:

Local (0.3 mi / 0.5 km)
Whittaker Woods Golf Course (1.9 mi / 3.1 km)
Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room (4.2 mi / 6.8 km)
St. Julian Winery - Union Pier Tasting Room (4.3 mi / 6.9 km)
Shady Creek Winery (6.5 mi / 10.5 km)
Oasis Splash Pad (9.3 mi / 15 km)

Exploring the beaches and other natural features in New Buffalo

Whether you're an adventurous traveller or just want to spend some time taking in the scenery, New Buffalo is a great place to spend some time outside. These are some of the area's most stunning natural features, all within 30 miles (48.2 km) of the city centre:

Indiana Dunes National Park (19.3 mi / 31 km)
New Buffalo Public Beach (0.5 mi / 0.8 km)
Galien River County Park (1.5 mi / 2.4 km)
Townline Beach (2.5 mi / 4.1 km)
Union Pier Beach (3.5 mi / 5.7 km)
Michiana Beach (3.7 mi / 6 km)

Seasonal weather in New Buffalo

If warm-weather activities are high on your list, July, August, June and September are the hottest months to visit, when temperatures average 21°C.

Transport to and around New Buffalo

Fly into South Bend, IN (SBN-South Bend Intl.), the closest airport, located 23.2 mi (37.4 km) from the city centre. If you can't find a flight that's convenient for your trip, you could book a flight to Chicago Midway Airport (MDW), which is 51.3 mi (82.6 km) away.

If you're travelling by train, the main station is New Buffalo Station.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best area to stay in New Buffalo when booking a holiday home?

One of the most sought-after neighbourhoods to get a holiday home in New Buffalo is Michiana. Find your perfect stay with Stayz and experience this area just like a local.

What is the most popular type of holiday home accommodation in New Buffalo?

According to our data, houses are the most sought-after holiday property type in New Buffalo. But of course, everyone's idea of an awesome stay is bound to be different. Stayz has holiday homes with every size, shape and budget in mind, so you're bound to find the best fit for your needs.

How much does it cost to rent a holiday home in New Buffalo?

A range of things can influence what you'll pay for your holiday home in New Buffalo, like the length of stay, type of property and season. But, all of our holiday homes have one thing in common --- incredible value. Just enter your travel dates to find your perfect fit.

How much does it cost to rent a beach house in New Buffalo?

The average price for a holiday home by the beach in New Buffalo depends on when you're going and the size and type of property you're looking for. You can find prices easily and quickly on Stayz by entering the dates you'll be travelling. Then use our filter tool to pick the number of bedrooms and amenities that you prefer, like WiFi, air conditioning and a pool.

Are there pet-friendly holiday homes in New Buffalo?

With 211 holiday homes that welcome pets, your furry companion can join in on your New Buffalo holiday. Use the filter tool to browse our pet-friendly holiday homes and find the pawfect pad on Stayz.

Can I rent a house with a pool in New Buffalo?

Tick the "pool" box in our filter tool and you can choose from 96 houses with private pools in New Buffalo on Stayz. Gentle soak, ball games or noodle joust? Leisure time is your call when your holiday property has a swimming pool.

What are popular home amenities in New Buffalo?

Some of the most popular home amenities guests are looking for in New Buffalo include a water view, a lake view and a fireplace. Whether you're going on holiday with friends, family or even pets, Stayz holiday properties provide the best amenities for chilling out with the people that matter most.

Are there large group holiday homes in New Buffalo?

Take your pick of 87 holiday homes in New Buffalo that can host 10 or more people. Whether you're organising a family holiday or a celebration like an anniversary, there's enough space to get your favourite people together under the same roof.

Are there holiday homes in New Buffalo that welcome kids?

Bring the entire family together for an unforgettable adventure in New Buffalo at one of our 211 family-friendly holiday properties. These stays come with conveniences that are suitable for trips with the kids, like dining rooms, living rooms and outdoor spaces. Just click on the "Properties good for families" filter and pick your favourite option.

What are the top attractions for families in New Buffalo?

Keeping the kids occupied during your stay in New Buffalo is a snap with these awesome family-friendly attractions:

New Buffalo Public Beach
Michiana Beach
Cherry Beach

Can I find two-bedroom holiday homes in New Buffalo?

You can select from 33 two-bedroom holiday homes in New Buffalo. Put your little ones in the second room or maybe fill it with a couple of your best friends. There's a comfy spot for whoever's fortunate enough to be coming along for the ride.

Are there holiday homes with WiFi in New Buffalo?

Whether you want to keep up with world events, write a few emails or update your social media, there are 69 holiday homes with WiFi in New Buffalo. Check the "WiFi" box when searching on Stayz and stay connected on your holiday.

How can I find holiday homes with air conditioning in New Buffalo?

You'll have a choice of 209 Stayz holiday homes with air conditioning in New Buffalo providing that cooling breeze and extra element of comfort. Enter your preferred dates of travel and then take advantage of our filter tool to help you find properties with air conditioning.

How old do you have to be to rent a holiday home in New Buffalo?

The minimum required age is usually 16, 18 or 21. It can change between properties on Stayz, so look at the rules of your chosen New Buffalo stay before booking your trip.

How long can I rent a holiday home in New Buffalo for?

It all depends on the New Buffalo property. To browse available options offering extended stays, simply type your dates and number of guests into the Stayz search page. You can look forward to having the place to yourself, along with amenities such as air conditioning, a kitchen and a backyard where the kids can run around and play. Be on the lookout for long-term stays that offer weekly or monthly discounts.