8/10 Good
Susan
22 May 2024
Liked: Cleanliness, amenities, property conditions & facilities, communication
The Gatsby was clean and nicely kept, with fun "Gatsby" themed decor. Access to wifi, printer (although we didn't need/use). We enjoyed the private back patio with plenty of seating and a hot tub - met another couple and had a really great conversation. Within quick drive of OSU, all of Grandview, North Market and downtown, German Village. Was able to find parking on the street. Has an alley garage, but very tight so didn't park there. While a cute and clean building and apt., there were a few slight cons that we felt need to be addressed in order to receive a 5-star rating: There was no curtain on the bathroom window, which looked directly into at least 3 of the neighbor's windows (buildings close) - we messaged host through the Expedia/VRBO message app upon arrival... after about 40 min. wait we purchased a spring rod and threw a towel over it; bathroom floor tiles in front of tub were loose and missing grout - moved when stepped on; the metal bedframe was very rickety and squeaky upon slightest movement, although the mattress was more comfortable than most hotels we've stayed in; the loveseat in the front room is a bit run down - could use a cleaning and restuffed back pillows; back door code pad did not work, so we just kept it locked while there and used front door. Would have liked host to respond to our message about the lack of bathroom curtain. Sharing a cell number would help. A little TLC in these areas would bring it up to 5-star.
Susan
Stayed 2 nights in May 2024
