I would rate this villa between 3 and 4 star. The location of the villa is just perfect with a stunning view! It is located within 7 minutes of the autostrada to Florence and Siena. And there are a lot of nice villages to visit close by. The atmosphere of the villa is cosy and authentic. But it must be said that the kitchen in the upper villa (the other ones we didn't use for practical reasons) and bathrooms are outdated and not very clean. Hot water in some of the showers was not very stable, it varied from very hot to very cold, when you were lucky somewhere in the middle. Also the shower areas were very small and not very clean. The owners were very friendly and always available for help, but were not able to fix the hot water problem in the showers.
However we had a great time, the pool area is great with more than enough sunbeds. And the long, covered diner table outside was perfect for our diners and playing board games. So we loved our stay, but in our opinion the kitchen and showers need an upgrade. So I would recommend the villa to a friend because of the location, but would mention our opinion on the bathrooms and kitchen.