Several small sailboats tied up or beached at Barnegat Bay on Long Beach Island

Mystic Island family rentals

We found 34 family rentals — enter your dates for availability

Where to?

Dates

Calendar
Flexible dates

December 2025

18

January 2026

Find the best place to stay - Mystic Island

There’s lots of time to boat, jet ski, paddle, swim, fish and even go crabbing

Premier Host

Cozy, Year-round Waterfront Cottage Near Historic Town-Pet Friendly!

Sleeps 6 · 2 bedrooms · 1 bathroom

Exterior

Brand New, Waterfront Beach Oasis with Heated Pool, Hot Tub, & Dock close to LBI

Sleeps 16 · 4 bedrooms · 3+ bathrooms

Views from the back of the house

Cozy Waterfront views 4 bedroom house in Charming Mystic Island - GUEST FAVORITE

Sleeps 12 · 5 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms

Dining

Premier Host

NEW REMODELED BUNGALOW!! Beautifully decorated on Lagoon in a great location

Sleeps 4 · 3 bedrooms · 1 bathroom

Amazing Bay Views, sunsets and your water toys parked in the backyard

Premier Host

Watersports paradise, 65ft floating dock, bay in front, lagoon in back yard

Sleeps 12 · 5 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms

Find spaces that suit your style

House

Condo/Apartment

00a185e2-8a6c-0be9-5553-6dab087ecdb79a8940e6-0d76-486b-ba2e-c87784b630db