Shelter Island rentals with pool

Excellent experience with home, location, and property owner

From the day of booking, Andrew and Morgan were responsive and wonderful to communicate with. So generous with their time and had fantastic suggestions for restaurants and activities for our Thanksgiving week in their home. The house exceeded our expectations. Fully equipped with everything you need, beautifully furnished and so comfortable for the two families. Lots of space for the kids to play and entertain themselves, indoors and out. The view is breathtaking, we had to photograph it every morning and evening! We loved the beach - (only 5 minutes walk) wineries, restaurants, groceries and great coffee shops only a short drive (or bicycle ride) away. Thank you Andrew and Morgan for sharing your home with us. We made wonderful Thanksgiving memories and were full of gratitude! We will definitely be back.

We stayed at Edward and Tracy’s oasis in Shelter island for a month. Words cannot express the magic of this house and property. We created lifelong memories, taking advantage of the amazing view, lawn and dock. We came during C-19 to shelter in place and escape NYC and there couldn’t have been a more perfect place with ample workstations, super fast wifi, a kitchen with all the gadgets for your at-home chef dreams and tranquility in the beautifully made up bedrooms that felt like you were in a boutique hotel! Edward and Tracy really made us feel safe, making sure we had ample supplies and ensuring the house was fully sanitized before we stayed. There is so much to do at the property that you don't ever need to leave including swimming off the dock, lovely picnics on the lawn at sun set, grilling on the patio, taking a bath that overlooks the water and meditating on the dock. This was perfect for us to shelter in place in shelter island :) Although we never really needed to leave we do highly recommend the lobster and oysters from Commander Cody after going for hikes in the nature preserve a mile away…! We couldn’t recommend their home more, we feel very grateful for Edward and Tracy opening up their house and they were an absolute pleasure in all of our communications and all. We cannot wait to go back. Thank you Edward and Tracy!