First the good: Large windows give very open, sunny atmosphere; Long dining table comfortably seats whole family; Screened porch is great and nice table allows outdoor dining and visiting; Secluded area is quiet, no bachelorette parties to disturb the peace.
The bad parts are relatively minor but overall the place feels old and worn. There is grime on the vents and the grout in bathrooms and especially the grout on the tiles in the kitchen counter. Walls are scuffed and baseboards dirty. A dirty throw rug in the bathroom and the kitchen were covered with hair. The wicker settee on the screen porch is old with peeling paint and mildewy cushion. Metal rails around the deck are rusted. To be fair, the important areas were clean -- the bed linens and refrigerator were clean. Bathrooms are not updated, but they are functional. There were no bath towels upstairs and the ones downstairs were so thin and worn, some had bleach stains. I don't expect beach towels, but for the price we paid, it felt insulting to not get a decent bath towel. I have rags at home that are better than what was there. As for the beds, note carefully that the master is a loft so if people downstairs are watching tv or talking, the person up in the loft may not sleep. The double bed is really small for 2 people. The couple in that room are small people but were so cramped she slept on a couch after the first night. Overall there are some great points to the place (nice dining area, great screen porch, quiet location, very sunny space) but for the price, I expected it would be cleaner, more updated.