Overall, we enjoyed our stay. The cottage is rustic, exactly as advertised, and the listing represents it fairly. The three separate cottages worked well for our group, the waterfront was beautiful, and Ali was always quick to respond to our questions.Our 3-star rating reflects avoidable management and maintenance issues, not the rustic nature of the property.The biggest issue was the garbage, recycling and compost process. The listing provides specific disposal limits at the bins near the end of the road, so we planned our stay accordingly. The day before checkout, however, we were told that all garbage, recycling and compost had to be taken to the landfill instead. This was frustrating because the cottage had no recycling or compost bins and only one small garbage can for a property that sleeps a large group. There was no practical way to sort and store waste during our stay. We were told the landfill was about 9 minutes away, but it was actually closer to 17 minutes each way. Fortunately, someone in our group had room in his truck and access to a bin at home. Otherwise, checkout would have been significantly more difficult.There are also a few maintenance items that should be addressed. One dock has a hole with exposed nail heads, another has low tree branches hanging over it, and the grounds could use some attention.Overall, we had a great weekend. With consistent checkout instructions and some basic maintenance, this would easily have been a 4- or 5-star stay.