We had an extraordinary week on Plum Island. If you are looking to relax and explore, to have a beach mostly to yourself, stay here.
First, the house - it is newly renovated, very spacious for one family (we are a family of four) and fine for two (if you don't mind sharing a bathroom). It is thoughtfully stocked with everything you need (towels, extra pillows, beach chairs, pots, pans, utensils and dishes). There is a huge, new comfy couch for reading and watching TV. Central air, individual units and ceiling fans work well. There are porches for breathing ocean air.
Plum Island is like living in another time and at another pace. It is a small town, where you don't feel like a tourist and where you mostly see people who are walking to the beach because it's their backyard. We loved walking 10 minutes to Mad Martha's for a cozy breakfast, and we loved exploring the quirky houses and porch life of the island as we took sunset walks. Plum Island is a nature preserve where you can explore as much as you have energy to do. We loved visiting Sandy Point at low tide, where our kids could run and splash in tidal pools, again with so few people around (Even in late August). The beach right by the house has glorious sunrises and is such a peaceful place. It is cold for swimming but fine for a quick wade in.
From Plum Island you can explore Newburyport (good food, events, activities), Amesbury (we loved blueberry and peach picking and fresh fruit ice cream at Cider Hill Farms) and drive a little further to Salem (great food and museums).
For us, it was a perfect week away, where we had space and time to ourselves, great town centers and few tourists (unlike past trips to Cape Cod). There were times when we were the only people on the beach as far as we could see. It was a gift.